When metrics become reality

These days it is difficult to discuss anything without numbers. We are surrounded by them, and perhaps more than before, we also trust them. How many followers someone has, how many people watched a video, how many times it was shared, how many citations a researcher has, where a university stands in a ranking, how many people attended an event. Numbers give us the feeling that we know something about a person, institution or event. But sometimes I wonder whether we have slowly started taking the number itself as reality. This came to mind while reading Jerry Z Muller’s The Tyranny of Metrics. Muller is not arguing that measurement is unnecessary. 

Measurement is useful, and in many situations institutions cannot function without it. His concern is what happens when a measurement that was initially used as an indicator slowly becomes a target, and people begin changing their behavior because of that target. At that point, the number is not only measuring what people do. It is also influencing what they do. 

I find this particularly relevant to the academic world. Researchers today live with many numbers around them: publications, citations, h-index, journal impact factors, research income, university rankings, downloads and increasingly different forms of digital attention. Universities need ways to demonstrate performance, and funding agencies need criteria for making decisions. But academic work is not always easy to capture through such measurements. A citation tells us that someone cited a paper, but not necessarily whether the paper was excellent, influential, or cited because someone disagreed with it. 

Still, once these numbers become connected with promotion, funding or reputation, researchers naturally pay attention to them. If citations matter for career progression, citations become part of how researchers think about their work. If publication in certain journals is valued more, researchers think about those journals. If universities are compared through particular indicators, universities think about those indicators. A measurement system can therefore become a way of organizing behavior.

We can see a similar development in political and public life, especially with the growth of social media in Nepal. Almost every public communication now comes with numbers. We know how many people follow a politician, how many watched a video, how many shared it and how many comments it received. Sometimes these numbers themselves become part of the political discussion. A person with a large following can be treated as more authentic than someone with fewer followers. A video with millions of views can be presented as evidence of influence. But what exactly does the number tell us? 

It tells us that a video was watched. It does not necessarily tell us why. Some viewers may agree, others may disagree, some may be curious, and some may simply have encountered the video because a platform recommended it. Similarly, having many followers tells us something about digital reach, but it does not automatically tell us that a person is more trustworthy or that everything they say is more authentic. This distinction matters when numbers are used to make larger conclusions. We can move from saying that a video received many views to saying that the person is influential, then from influence to popularity, legitimacy or political strength. 

At every stage, we move a little further away from what the original number actually tells us. This is not an argument against any particular politician, minister or social media personality. The issue is larger than any individual. All of us are becoming part of this environment. We see that something has many followers and give it more attention. We see that something has gone viral and assume it must be important. We see a large number of comments and may think they represent public opinion. Sometimes they may. But they may also represent what the platform has chosen to make visible. 

This is where Muller’s argument becomes more interesting than a simple criticism of metrics. The problem is not merely that people use numbers. Once numbers become important, people start responding to them. A politician notices what kind of content receives attention and produces more of it. A university notices which indicators affect its ranking and gives greater attention to those indicators. A researcher sees what kind of publication helps career progression and acts accordingly. A media organization sees which stories generate clicks and gives more space to those stories. None of this necessarily means that people are doing something wrong. They may simply be responding rationally to the environment in which they work. 

But when everyone responds this way, the environment itself begins to change. We are no longer only measuring things. We are also changing the things we measure. The number becomes an incentive, the incentive changes behavior, and the changed behavior produces new numbers. Those numbers are then used to make further judgments. 

Perhaps this is why the issue is not only about politicians or universities. It is becoming part of ordinary life. We increasingly live in a world where visibility is measurable. A person can see immediately how many people follow them. A politician can see how many people watched a speech. A researcher can see how many times a paper has been cited. A university can see where it stands in a ranking. Numbers make comparison easy, but comparison also creates pressure. Once we know that a number matters, it becomes difficult not to think about increasing it. 

The real question, then, may not be whether metrics are good or bad. We need them, and they can tell us useful things. The question is whether we remember that they are indicators rather than reality itself. A citation is an indicator. A ranking is an indicator based on a particular methodology. A follower count indicates digital reach. A video view indicates attention. None of these numbers, by itself, gives us the complete picture. Numbers can appear more objective than other forms of judgment. Saying that someone has one million followers or that a university holds a particular ranking position feels more concrete than saying that someone is influential or that a university has a strong intellectual environment. But the fact that something can be expressed precisely does not necessarily mean that it captures the thing precisely. 

In Nepal, as political communication and public discussion become increasingly digital, this is worth thinking about. We will have more followers, more views, more rankings, more dashboards and more ways of measuring almost everything. There is nothing wrong with that by itself. But we should be careful not to confuse measurement with reality. Because once everyone starts taking the metric as reality, the metric is no longer just telling us about the world. We start changing the world according to the metric. And perhaps this is where we all become trapped in it, not because someone designed the trap for us, but because all of us, in different ways, are participating in making it.